9. Wally Schang
Schang was the starting catcher for New York for three straight American League pennants (1921-23) and earned himself a World Series ring in 1923.
In five years in the Bronx. Schang slashed .297/.390/.406 with 16 home runs and 209 RBI but in 32 World Series games, he went 27-for-94 with one home run and eight RBI.