3. Don Mattingly

Speaking of home runs, never has Yankee Stadium been so loud when Don Mattingly hit his first, and only playoff home run in 1995.

If this list happened to be “most beloved,” then Mattingly would surely finish first, despite the fact the captain only made the postseason once.

While he’ll never make the Hall of Fame, Mattingly can hang his hat on the fact no Yankee legend will forever be remembered as fondly.