5. Don Mattingly’s Yankees
Coming in to start the list is a team that, to be honest, wasn’t the most popular. A better description might be frustrating.
Other candidates included Jason Kidd’s New Jersey Nets, the 1992-93 New York Islanders, the Sack-Exchange New York Jets, and the 1979 New York Rangers.
Nevertheless, Don Mattingly’s New York Yankees take the No. 5 spot.
The sole reason? Well, because Mattingly was that popular among Yankee fans.
Not only could this team never win a title, they only made the postseason once in this era (1995). Guys like Ricky Henderson and Dave Winfield always allowed George Steinbrenner’s team to generate back-page publicity, but the lack of pitching always prevented them from winning the AL East crown.