6. Scarlett Johansson

Another rumor that seemed to have a distinct possibility of being valid. Spotted having dinner in 2004, it appeared as if a baseball and move star were intertwining.

Again, this may have been pure speculation. However, Jeter deserves props for even getting a dinner date with this woman.

Just that lone accomplishment gets her decent recognition compared to some of the more prominent candidates.

 Next: Girlfriend No. 5