10. Tyra Banks
Back in 2001, Jeter was spotted with the model and television personality at a New York Knicks basketball game.
Although the two never officially confirmed a relationship, the media usually tends to think realistically and connect the dots. While it may have been a completely false speculation, few would doubt that the shortstop — after enjoying an MVP caliber campaign — would want anything less.
Given some of his more glorified relationships, this one makes logical sense.
