2. Minka Kelly
This particular swing hit the jackpot. The Friday Night Lights star dated the Yankee shortstop from 2008 to 2011 while he pulled off numerous feats in his career.
Pure media attention is what broke this one apart. Briefly getting back together in 2012, there were rumors surrounding the two getting married.
While it seemed to be a fit for both, the stress involving the heavy attention got the better of them. As far as attractiveness and longevity, the match worked. With the exception of Davis, Kelly was the longest tenured fling.
