1. Joe Montana (QB-SF)
Nobody can surpass Joe Montana for tops on this list.
Not only is he tied with Brady and Bradshaw for the most Super Bowl victories in history as quarterback, he’s perfect. And this doesn’t just mean a perfect 4-0, it means his script was flawless.
Whether it was a 55-10 blowout, like we saw in Super Bowl XXIV against John Elway’s Denver Broncos, or a two-minute drive against the Cincinnati Bengals in Super Bowl XXIII that started with a John Candy spotting in the crowd, Montana has done it all.
Montana collected three Super Bowl MVPs, had 11 touchdowns to zero interceptions, and owns the record for best passer rating for a career in the big game with a ridiculous 127.8 mark.